In today's digitally-driven market, U.S.-based contractors and service businesses frequently grapple with deciding whether to invest more heavily in their website or social media presence. This blog post dives deeply into the strengths of each platform, highlighting key statistics and insights that reveal which builds more trust and generates better conversions.
Credibility and Trust: Professional Authority vs Social Proof
Websites
A professional website is foundational for credibility. Over 92% of consumers check a company's website before hiring a service provider, and 30% won't consider a business without one. Additionally, 75% of consumers admit judging a business's credibility based solely on website design. Clearly, a professionally built, modern website signals reliability, legitimacy, and professionalism, essential traits for attracting high-quality leads.
Social Media
Social platforms build trust differently—primarily through engagement, social proof, and reviews. Approximately 67% of consumers rely heavily on customer reviews and discussions found on social media when making purchasing decisions. However, skepticism remains, with only 41% inherently trusting information on social media. Regular engagement and timely responses on platforms like Facebook and Instagram can mitigate this skepticism and enhance perceived trustworthiness.
Branding Control and Content Ownership
Websites
Contractors have complete branding control with a custom-built website—from visual design to messaging. This allows for consistent brand presentation, precise communication of services, portfolios, testimonials, and secure customer data ownership. Unlike social media platforms, there's no risk of losing visibility overnight due to algorithm changes. Partnering with a reliable web agency ensures that your branding remains professional, compelling, and fully customized to your target audience.
Social Media
Social platforms offer limited branding control—you're essentially "renting" digital real estate. Algorithmic changes can drastically reduce your visibility overnight, and platform rules constrain creative freedom. Despite these constraints, social media allows businesses to showcase personality through authentic daily interactions, humanizing the brand significantly and creating genuine connections.
SEO and Discoverability: Being Found Online
Websites
SEO (Search Engine Optimization) is a substantial advantage of having a dedicated website. With 97% of consumers utilizing search engines to locate local service providers, websites optimized for targeted local search terms (e.g., "plumbers in Seattle") capture high-intent leads effectively. Leads generated through organic search are typically more qualified and ready to convert, making SEO services offered by web agencies essential for sustained growth.
Social Media
Social media excels at organic discovery and referrals. Approximately 58% of consumers initially discover new businesses through social media platforms. Although platforms provide some search features, they generally fall short compared to dedicated website SEO capabilities. The primary strength of social media is network-driven visibility rather than direct searchability.
Lead Generation and Conversions: Turning Interest into Customers
Websites
Custom-built websites are explicitly designed to convert visitors into qualified leads. Clear calls-to-action, intuitive contact forms, click-to-call features, and optimized landing pages significantly increase conversions. Statistics show 63% of consumers prefer engaging with service providers directly through their websites. Moreover, conversion rates from website traffic substantially outperform social media traffic, reflecting higher intent among website visitors.
Social Media
Social media is best for initial engagement, nurturing potential leads, and maintaining brand awareness. While it effectively generates interest, significant conversions, especially for high-ticket services like contracting and construction projects, generally happen via websites or direct communication channels. Still, positive social media interactions matter—63% of consumers plan to engage with businesses after a favorable social media interaction.
Customer Decision Behavior
Consumers typically interact with both websites and social media platforms throughout their decision-making process. About 70–80% of people thoroughly research businesses online before making direct contact. Websites verify professionalism, showcase expertise through portfolios, and clarify service details, while social media provides real-time insights into business activity and customer sentiment. Notably, younger demographics heavily utilize social media, with 72% of millennials influenced significantly by social interactions during their decision-making process.
Conclusion
Ultimately, both websites and social media are indispensable tools in a comprehensive digital marketing strategy for contractors. Websites provide authoritative credibility, SEO visibility, and robust conversion capabilities. Social media platforms offer dynamic engagement, enhance community trust, and significantly amplify reach through peer recommendations. The ideal strategy integrates both platforms, employing social media to funnel prospects towards professionally developed, high-performing websites for final conversions.
Sources
- Blue Corona Contractor Marketing Report
- Synup Social Proof Statistics
- Reputationx Online Reputation Management Statistics
- Clutch Small Business Websites Survey
- GC Sherpa Social Media Marketing Guide
- Invesp Conversion Rate Statistics
- Ruth Gaunt, Why Your Small Business Needs a Website and Why Relying on Social Media Isn't Enough
Ready to Build Your Digital Presence?
We've helped countless contractors and service businesses build powerful digital presences that convert. Whether you need a professional website, social media strategy, or both, we're here to help.